Week 12-1

https://jngeist.com/believe/

Three Claims from the Comic

  1. George Washington's teeth were not made of wood.
  2. George Washington's teeth were from a bunch of different animals.
  3. George Washington had a set of teeth made from the teeth of enslaved people.

For each of these claims:

  • What do the comic's sources say? How much do we trust those sources?
  • What can we find in our own research to confirm or complicate those statements?

What did we find out?

The Nightmare Teeth

The Saddest Fact

In a drawer in the Locker of the Desk which stands in my study you will find two small (fore) teeth; which I beg of you to wrap up carefully, and send inclosed [sic] in your next letter to me. I am positive I left them there, or in the secret drawer in the locker of the same desk.

"The Trouble With Teeth", Mount Vernon.

Truth is complex and specific.

The Oatmeal overstates things.

According to his account books, in 1784, emulating some of his affluent friends, he bought nine teeth from unidentified “Negroes” — perhaps enslaved African-Americans at his beloved Mount Vernon; the price was 122 shillings.

"George Washington's Weakness: His Teeth", The New York Times

Lund Washington, George’s distant cousin who managed Mount Vernon during the Revolution, made a notation in the plantation ledger books for May 1784: “By Cash pd Negroes for 9 Teeth on Acct of Dr. Lemoire.” This “Dr. Lemoire” was almost certainly George Washington’s dentist, Dr. Jean Le Mayeur, who corresponded with George Washington about his visit to Mount Vernon that summer.

"Did George Washington's false teeth come from his slaves?", George Washington Papers, emphasis mine.

Wherever Dr. Le Mayeur practiced, he sought out through newspaper ads “Persons who are willing to dispose of their Front Teeth.” While in New York, he advertised that he would pay two guineas each for good front teeth; in Richmond, he stipulated “slaves excepted.” That could explain why the price noted by Lund Washington was so low. Nine teeth sold for two guineas each would be worth almost nineteen pounds; Washington paid only slightly more than six pounds.

"Did George Washington's false teeth come from his slaves?", George Washington Papers, emphasis mine.

This is where the limitations of history come into play. The only documentation of which we are aware of George Washington purchasing teeth from slaves is a brief notation in his ledger books.1 The physical evidence, a pair of Washington’s dentures that includes human teeth, is part of the collection at Mount Vernon.2 As to the circumstances surrounding the creation of these dentures, the best historians can do is make an educated guess. Like all historical theories, this conclusion should be grounded in historical context, supplemental primary and secondary documents, and sound reasoning. But without further documentation, it is impossible to describe the scenario in definitive terms. We are not even entirely positive that the teeth whose price is recorded in the Ledger Book are the same as those in the dentures.

"Did George Washington's false teeth come from his slaves?", George Washington Papers, emphasis mine.